MDA in Aza
Door: Bram
Blijf op de hoogte en volg Bram
27 Januari 2008 | Israel, Holon
Hi everybody, I started MDA (Magen David Adom) the ambulance service. It is great fun! The station in Holon is amazing and so are our apartments. I miss Jerusalem though. The training week was amazing I met a lot of old friends there and made a lot of new ones. But it is good to have a place for myself again. We are doing everything by ourselves now. We kook, clean and shop together. The place we live on the city limit and looks out over fields all the way up to Tel-Aviv we are not to far from the centre of town though and Tel-Aviv is close too so we have everything we need close by. Our first shabath together was fantastic except for the fact that I was terribly sick most of the time. We had a few guys over who are doing Marva (two months of army training) and we also had some guys over who are doing MDA in Netanya so the houses were packed.
Here is a small assay about one of the calls I had so far.
On the subject of ethics.
What I give you here is a report of something I witnessed here as a volunteer in the ambulance service of Israel, Magen David Adom. I do not give my opinion although you may ask it of me if you want and I will answer. I will try to give you all the important details and such. Here it goes.
Last Wednesday I was working my first shift during my gap year (I have worked shifts before) in my station in Holon (Cholon for the Dutch people) in the centre of Israel. At around 15:30 we got a call from for a patient who needed to be transferred from a hospital in Tel-Aviv to Aza (Gaza). We, the driver, a boy who was doing his national service and me, went from Holon to Tel-Aviv. This took us about 20 minutes. In Tel-Aviv we double checked the Ambulance for all the necessities. We found that we were short of one helmet. So we waited for someone to bring us one. (Another 20 minutes) Now we went in to the hospital to get our patient and her brother, both of them in there late fifties or early sixties. The woman wasn’t really talking but the brother was talking to my driver in broken Hebrew, he seemed to be a very polite and kind man. He was telling us about his stay in Tel-Aviv and how he was sorry to bother us with their entire luggage but they had been in Tel-Aviv for 30 days. Then there was some paperwork to be done and soon we were off. During the ride to the border there was not much talking. From the few words of Arabic I had picked up during my volunteering in Ashdod I understood that the woman was in a lot of pain and was praying. I tried to calm her down and she soon fell asleep and sitting in the front, so did I. I woke up and noticed that everybody was pretty tense. We were at Askelon and would soon reach the border.
I soon found out what was bothering everybody. “Just today there were 40 kasam rockets on S’derot and 30 on Ashkelon, it’s still light, there might be more to come.” My driver told me. Fortunately we reached the border without any rockets falling close to us. (I think a few more hit in S’derot just 10 kilometers south-west of us but I am not sure). At the checkpoint started the endless paperwork and then we had to drive up to the border. We parked the ambulance on one side of the 4 meter tall wall and waited. Soon a soldier came to check our clearance. Then a man came who took the luggage and the patient without saying a word. He disappeared beyond the wall and soon came back with our ambulance bed. The patient had been transferred to a Palestinian Ambulance about 25 minutes after we arrived at the checkpoint, fully 2 hours after we got the call.
We took one more, long look at Aza, it was so quite now, dead quite. We returned to the Ambulance and we were of back home.
This all raised a lot of questions to me, such as “Should a country give medical help to people who are not their own citizens?” “Should patients be transferred through such an unsafe zone?” “Is all the paperwork not dangerous for the patient?” “Were should we draw the line between personal care for the patient and national safety?” And many more, which I am sure you can also think of. Than there was of course my private question of where I would draw my line when in comes to taking risks for patients. I think I figured it all out for myself now.
Now I am curious to hear your thoughts on this.
See you soon,
Bram.
P.S. next time I'll tell you about how I flooded my apartment.
-
27 Januari 2008 - 18:32
Samuel:
Tsja Bram,
Je weet dat dit soort situaties zich kunnen voordoen, je hebt vast ook andere verhalen gehoord van mensen die MDA deden voor jou tijd dus heel raar vind ik het niet eens.
Wel heel gaaf dat je hier zo goed over nadenkt, veel mensen laten het langs hun heengaan maar jij niet, echt knap!
Mijn mening?
Patient is patient, en je doet wat je moet doen om hem of haar te helpen, dat is waar je het werk voor doet...
Hoop dat het verder goed met je gaat, en ik kan niet wachten om te horen hoe je je appartement onder water hebt gekregen ;)
Groeten uit Amstelveen
Samuel Swartz. -
27 Januari 2008 - 19:14
Elsien:
Ik hoorde van Nynke van je overstroming.. Als echte Nederlanderr toch maar weer opgelost met dijkjes bouwen?
Wie was die nare man nou waarom je de telefoon voor je meest gelieve zusje moest ophangen!!!?
Stomme nare man! (die binnen kwam) en wat een domme vraag: 'is this an appartment?' .. nee natuurlijk niet.. Het is een dierentuin.. =S
Bel je nog wel even.. Kun je donderdag aaf bellen (huisarts bezoek en eerste werkdag bij Jossie! )
Kus
-
28 Januari 2008 - 01:17
Bram:
Ik doelde meer op: kan je de patient met een goed hart terug sturen naar Gaza als je weet van de crisis daar en mag je je laten vertragen door papierwerk etc. maar over dat je doet wat je moet doen ben ik het wel eens met je. Patient is natuurlijk in de eerste plaats patient.
En die kerel was een buurman en de vraag was geldig gezien we in een school wonen! -
28 Januari 2008 - 15:19
Lieuwe:
Doe gewoon wat je moet doen.
Het liefst natuurlijk zonder er zelf bij in te schieten. :)
grtz Lieuwe
P.S. leuke site, ben benieuwd naar het volgende verhaal -
28 Januari 2008 - 22:25
Oren Zomer:
1. Yes - as an humanitarian aid in times of crisis - supporting basic human rights are the base for every democracy. But don't turn it to a situation where they count on your free\cheap hospitals instead of building their own.
2. Should people live in such an unsafe zone? Should people drive when it's so unsafe on the roads? If you fight on your right to live in your land, than the only way to win is to live in your land - with the required defense system ofcourse..
3. Aniyey Ircha Kodmim - "The poors of your own city are first". And if you decided to give foreign aid, in this world there are plenty of people who'll need it - you don't have to help those who were, or may will be, on the side of your enemy. Let's help the Darfurian refugees who knock on our borders, the Gazans can ask their brothers in egypt for aid.
hmm.. that's my opinion at least. If a man believes that you stole a dollar from him, you won't convince him to give up by giving him a penny. -
29 Januari 2008 - 16:03
Rafi:
how many countries do you know would be treating the sick patients of their enemies? -
31 Januari 2008 - 00:25
Bram:
Well spoken Oren I agree with most although you know as well as I that Egyptians despise the Palestinians and won't lift a finger to help them except to destroy Israel. And Rafi I think that Israel is the ONLY country in the world who does that. -
31 Januari 2008 - 07:46
Roos:
wow bram...
wat een verhalen!
ik ben blij dat je er zo enthousiast bent.
ik heb niet heel veel te vertellen(want we hebben gister al gesproken)
dus tot ziens... -
01 Februari 2008 - 20:51
Frits:
Ha die Bram,
Ik lees je blog geregeld, al reageer ik nu voor de eerste keer. Als ik dit zo bekijk maak je nogal wat mee zeg! Pas je goed op jezelf?
Frits Mostert -
12 Februari 2008 - 18:16
Metta:
..en toen was mn batterij leeg. "Metta ik voel me verwaarloosd! Met wie ben je nu al de hele tijd aan het bellen!?" Leuk om je even te spreken :D
Liefs! -
16 Februari 2008 - 19:03
Bram:
METTAAAAAAAAAAAA wie was die kerel nou? -
17 Februari 2008 - 14:12
Metta:
Maarten, studiegenoot van mij, en nee, ik heb niet met m gezoend :p
Reageer op dit reisverslag
Je kunt nu ook Smileys gebruiken. Via de toolbar, toetsenbord of door eerst : te typen en dan een woord bijvoorbeeld :smiley